If there ever was a responding phrase that people say that really gets under my skin, it is, "Good for you." What the hell does that mean? This response pins you in a hole, makes you want to scream and makes it uncomfortable to even respond. This is especially true when it is said in a quasi-patronizing tone highlighting the fact that this person has nothing else to say. They are literally at a lost of words, do not know how to have a conversation, or they are not engaged in conversation as they should be. Here are some examples.
Example #1
Man 1: How are you today?
Man 2: I am well. I feel good and the weather is nice!
Man 1: Good for you!
This exchange of dialogue obviously shows an attempt from Man 2 to add life to such a boring question that we are asked every day. Man 1 obviously does not give a shit and he tries to make it sound like he empathetic, by saying, "Good for you." I always want to say, "No shit asshole. Of course it is good for me when I feel good!"
Example #2
Man 1: I heard you sold your company and are moving to New York?
Man 2: Yeah dude. I sold my company after spending about 1 year working on the deal. Finally, it happened and I found a sweet apartment that is perfect for me. I am really happy everything is working out and I now have a place. It will take some time to get established, but it will all come in time.
Man 1: Good for you!
What the fuck? Good for you? No shit asshole. Is this all you can say after a very detailed answer was giving to your question. Man 2 offered so much information that could have been used to ask a follow-up question and continue to have a conversation. The most obvious follow-up question is, "Oh that is fantastic. Where is your apartment?" Instead of this, you get "good for you", which clearly shows that Man 1 did not really care about an answer from Man 2. In fact, they really were not listening. The question was only asked to fill silence and out of obligation because maybe the two have not seen each other for some time. This is very similar to a buzz kill. You have few brews and you are feeling good only to have a friend do something to end the good sensation. If there were ever an ultimate escape from a conversation, this "Good for you" provides that route.
Example #3
Man 1: I hear you are going to Dental School. Where are you going?
Man 2: Yes, I am. After 2 years in the making, I will be going to Penn’s Dental School. It took a lot of work, but I am so excited to actually get going.
Man 1: Good for you
All I can do is shake my head in disgust to this response. I cannot even provide a, “No shit”. Maybe what I should do is to ask the question, “Why do you think it is good for me?” Or even, “You do really think it is good for me?” This would put the, “I do not give a shit response” back on their shoulders. This response tells me that they do not really care and they feel obligated to give a response. Well, I have news. If you don’t care, you don’t have to ask the question in the first place.
The moral of this story is to simply lose this phrase. Never, ever say this because it leads to a dead-end. It shows a lack compassion or empathy towards the other person. It says that you really could care less and you are asking questions only to have a dialogue with the person. In other words, you really do not want to have a conversation. Additionally, if you say this to me, I will call you on it and believe me, it will be “Good for you”.